I have an idea for a game: It's the usual "a princess is kidnapped by a dragon and a brave knight is on a quest to rescue her" story. But you (the player) plays as the princess, who is somehow helping the knight on his quest.

The issue is that since the player is playing as a trapped character, I want to make the player feel trapped, but I don't know how to do that.

My original idea is that the princess telepathically communicates with the knight and tells him what to do. But this doesn't work, the gameplay is identical to the player playing as the knight. How can I make the gameplay feel like the player is playing as the princess (and thus feel trapped) instead of the knight?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[–] Sunsofold@lemmings.world 9 points 1 day ago (1 children)

If you want to produce the sensation of being trapped you have to use the feeling of power and loss. It stems from the sense of 'If I could just...' If I could just get out there, I could defeat that henchman for him. If I could just get out there, I could solve that riddle for him. If I could just escape this box, all would be fixed.

Now, the trick is, because this is a video game, players have a reduced sense of agency. The player's sense of capacity is 'what happens when you hit the button.' Mario, before more modern adaptations, had a capacity to move left and right, jump, run, and 'use ability.' The player never had the ability to do anything else, so it never feels like a limitation. No one ever said, 'playing Mario makes me feel trapped because I could beat Bowser if I could just access the cannon that's right over there.'

So, to produce the feeling of confinement, one must create the sense of power, and then take it away. Give the player enough power that they could even defeat the dragon, but then take it from them so they feel limited. If you can find a way to make it feel like it's not even forced, as in they feel like they could have won the game in Act 1, Scene 1, but their ~~lack of~~ skills as a player were what made them lose, all the better.

[–] ajoebyanyothername@lemmy.world 1 points 1 day ago

Would that be your classic 'meant to lose' fight, usually against the big bad, which is technically winnable but the vast majority of players will lose and progress the story as planned? The example that comes to mind is Ghost of Tsushima, but it crops up in plenty of games.