this post was submitted on 05 Aug 2025
51 points (98.1% liked)
Rust
7232 readers
5 users here now
Welcome to the Rust community! This is a place to discuss about the Rust programming language.
Wormhole
Credits
- The icon is a modified version of the official rust logo (changing the colors to a gradient and black background)
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
I'm assuming that's been there for a while since this was topical six months ago.
Anyway, while I am no fan of Musk or the site formerly known as Twitter, I think this is a bad thing. The author's political views have been prioritised over users' abilities to use the site; even if someone wanted to monitor X users in a way lib.rs approved of they couldn't get help from the site to do this.
I think lib.rs has pulled stunts like this before, which is why crates.rs is usually recommended instead.
Fighting Nazis, exposing Nazis, calling Nazis Nazis, etc are not political views. The are the only correct and sane thing to do for anyone.
lib.rs has always been more opinionated, because it isn't an official project. I imagine, those who look for opinionated will have no problem with this. It certainly made me like the site more.
Everything on the internet is shaped by political views. I don’t understand this take at all. All of the internet projects started as defense projects run by people that believed information should be shared and were taken over to become surveillance institutions. The notion that someone should run a free website indexing all rust crates is itself greatly informed by the politics surrounding FOSS and open information. How you respond to the paradox of tolerance is deeply political. We just happen to fall of different sides of the issue so I have no qualms calling it out.
Lib.rs could call it out and still return results for the search. Having said that, you can still view https://lib.rs/keywords/twitter or https://lib.rs/search?q=%22twitter%22 without any commentary, so it's workaroundable (or inconsistent).
I don't have a view on this particular case, but "calling it out" whilst still functioning effectively as normal is essentially a strongly-worded letter. F, and I can't stress this enough, that. Protest cannot be subdued by convenience.
Ohh, boohoohoo, what are you gong to do, cancel your lib.rs subscription?
There is a difference between the influence and reflection of politics in everything we do, and an actively politically motivated action. Not that the latter is a bad thing.
Yeah also calling anything where you raise your hand a "Nazi-like salute" is dumb af. Musk does enough real shit without having clutch at straws like this.
Musk is a fascist.
Oh of course that was just raising the hand. Sure bud. The timing and context also was perfectly suited to do "raise your hand" like you've waited your whole life for it, isn't it?
Or that he's been running a far-right social media platform on the internet. Or that he was supporting a president who ran on pale supremacy rhetoric. Or he was some rich guy that benefitted from apartheid south africa.
Nah, those are just coincidences. Just raising a hand, nothing more.
Oh, he was also around that time part of a German party assembly. You know of the party where top politicians say things like. "The Nazis where not that bad" or " The Problem with the holocaust was, that it didn't finish." That was probably an accident and misunderstanding too.
https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/bundestagswahl/parteien/musk-afd-wahlkampfshow-100.html
The title points out the problem. It DOESN'T MATTER what he intended; we already know his views. What matters is the message it sent to far-right supporters across the globe. He never made an attempt to address that.