this post was submitted on 19 Feb 2025
25 points (96.3% liked)

Lemmy

12778 readers
108 users here now

Everything about Lemmy; bugs, gripes, praises, and advocacy.

For discussion about the lemmy.ml instance, go to !meta@lemmy.ml.

founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
nutomic@lemmy.ml
25
RFC: "kicking" posts instead of removing them (lemmy.ml)
submitted 3 days ago* (last edited 3 days ago) by morrowind@lemmy.ml to c/lemmy@lemmy.ml
14 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 

(I haven't submitted an official rfc yet, want to see what people think)

This is inspired by Ruqqus, a now defunct Reddit alternative.

The idea is simple:

  1. There is a "global" or "default" community with no topic or extra rules, ~~moderated only by admins~~
  2. Community moderators, when they feel a post is inappropriate for their community can "kick" a post to the global community

The reasoning is as follows: a good amount, probably the majority of posts that are removed by mods, are not removed because they are inappropriate for the site as a whole, but because they are inappropriate for that specific community (off-topic, banned site, low effort, etc.). But currently the only option they have to deal with this is a full blown removal, which is quite frustrating for the poster.

This proposal would allow mods to keep curated communities without needing to do unnecessary removals.

As a bonus, this would create a default community where people can post when they're not sure where to post something. Posts can be later be crossposted into more specific communities.

top 14 comments
sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] Rogue@feddit.uk 12 points 3 days ago (2 children)

Yes.

It has always been a pet peeve of mine that I would find an interesting topic while browsing all on reddit, with a healthy number of upvotes and comments but regardless mods will bluster in and lock it because it's not quite on topic.

Back in the early days of Internet forums when moderators found an off topic post they would move it to the relevant sub , and there would typically be an "Other", "Off-Topic" or "Random" as a catch all.

I've never understood why threaded social media is missing such a basic moderation function.

[–] nutomic@lemmy.ml 9 points 3 days ago (1 children)

There is an open issue for moving posts to a different community which would allow for this functionality. But so far no one has worked on it yet.

[–] ladfrombrad@lemdro.id 6 points 3 days ago

It's definitely something we could get on board with over in !android@lemdro.id and shunting app requests etc that belong over in the respective !askandroid@lemdro.id community.

But I think like @Dessalines said re-writing posts rings true with us because over on reddit, when we got to a post that violated our rules but had already met a threshold of engagement (100 votes / 10 comments) before we got to it left it up (with a sticky comment explaining why) regardless.

Anyhoo, my 2c and thanks for all your work :)

[–] Kichae@lemmy.ca 5 points 3 days ago

Because it abandoned the idea of the site admins being responsible for moderation, in the name of expanding to unmanagable size.

On Reddit and Facebook, groups do not have a common moderation team, so they lack the right to dump a post in someone else's group.

[–] ShellMonkey@lemmy.socdojo.com 7 points 3 days ago

I could see two significant problems here.

1: people getting lazy and just chucking everything into the generic bucket and the admins/global mods having a mess to deal with.

2: I'm the event of an ability to move content to another community other than the instance 'global' how do you deal with cross-instance moves? For example if the most prominent version of a comm is on one instance but a post gets put on another, the logical place would be to be on the more prominent community, but just dumping posts on another instance isn't going to be well received I would guess.

[–] Aedis@lemmy.world 4 points 3 days ago (1 children)

I thing there's something here. I don't think that this is the solution though.

What I think is good:

  • A default place for posts
  • A way to remove posts from a community without nuking the user's post
  • Possibilities of cross posting and for de-duping efforts

What I think is bad:

  • A default community managed by admins (unscalable)
  • seems like a huge deviation from the current activity pub spec (which is kinda terrible ngl)
  • will need a very specific adapter to keep compatibility with other existing activity pub front ends.
[–] morrowind@lemmy.ml 2 points 3 days ago (1 children)

We could certainly have mods for this default community too, that's not crucial to the idea.

Could you expand in where this conflicts with activitypub? I thought AP was too general to care about something like this

[–] ladfrombrad@lemdro.id 2 points 3 days ago

We could certainly have mods for this default community too, that's not crucial to the idea.

It is thou, and why /r/reddit.com got archived eventually since the reddit admins (mods) couldn't keep up.

Where do you pool them from?

[–] Valmond@lemmy.world 3 points 3 days ago* (last edited 3 days ago) (1 children)

Maybe several "global" like one for good pists that doesn't belong on a specific sub, one for low effort memes,one for NSFW etc.

[–] morrowind@lemmy.ml 1 points 3 days ago

Maybe a NSFW one, but beyond that I feel like it would defeat the point

[–] JASN_DE@lemmy.world 3 points 3 days ago (1 children)

While I can see the appeal, it would probably need what amounts to a different system, I.e. not Lemmy.

[–] morrowind@lemmy.ml 1 points 3 days ago

I'm no expert on how lemmy is implemented, but I don't see why not. Would probably just involve a post removal + a post creation, with some scaffolding code to handle the uglier details

[–] onoira@lemmy.dbzer0.com 2 points 3 days ago* (last edited 3 days ago) (1 children)

i like this. i think for now as a workaround: one could lock the topic and leave a comment asking the OP to crosspost it elsewhere, with grace for posts which have high engagement (as ladfrombrad suggested).

i don't agree that crossposting works to 'move' posts. as far as i know: the OP is not notified when their topic is crossposted by someone else, and in that case they also won't be 'subscribed' to comment notifications.

[–] ladfrombrad@lemdro.id 1 points 3 days ago

So furthering on this would shunting things to a !bucket@instance.com (maybe a somewhat better named community since I'm terribad at these things might work better....) within Instances but still viewable and crosspost-able by other, Instance users?

This would negate the need for a global admin since the Instance could have mods of that particular /c/, allowing the other Instance admins to review it for suitably if and when they drop in?