Prunebutt
That only works for so long, because the system isn't stable that way. Capitalism requires some sort of exploitation. If that exploitation is hindered for too long, capitalism will become in crisis.
This chapter explains why that deal didn't continue in Europe
Also: if you tax the rich too much, they will conduct a capital strike, where they stdpinvesting in the country, or move their business somewhere else. That bit isn't just a bogeyman from conservatives. It has some merit. Social democracy just isn't a stable system.
Yeah... and hou sustainable did it turn out to be?
Is this loss?
but the degree to which it furthers society is difficult to quantise.
That's because "furthering of society" doesn't have a well defined metric.
... so why quantise it at all?
How is it going in the mental model of the 1950s?
No where here did we make it facist saying "you did not come from here, get out." That is not our argument.
I disagree. I think that's a core assumend premise of the video. Otherwise, the statement that Bibi's from Poland doesn't make any coherent sense as an argument.
I disagree with the complete "blood and soil" premise that zionism is based on. But I critisize bs logic, no matter which camp it stated.
I don't know what else to tell you. "People don't belong in places were their ancestors aren't from" is the literal opinion of current real-world racists.
I don't really adhere to the logic that anargument loses it's characteristics if you're unable to enforce it.
If I'm exclaiming "death to all jews", it's still antisemitic if I'm unable to hurt a single person.
I really don't want to downplay the suffering that indigenous peoples are still enduring due to colonization. But the "your ancestors are from xyz, so you don't belong in abc" is the core statement of ethnopluralism. It doesn't get better if you're being an ethnonationalist/ethnopluralist in favour of the "right" peoples.
How is this argument different from ethnopluralism?
How did the anarchist collectives "[fail] for human dickish reasons"? Is outside pressure from fascists a problem inherent to socialism?