lol I was banned today for “failure to grow” because i did not have the proper thinking.
It was on me though. I should not have commented there, knowing what happens regularly.
This is a community in the spirit of "Am I The Asshole" where people can post their own bans from lemmy or reddit or whatever and get some feedback from others whether the ban was justified or not.
Sometimes one just wants to be able to challenge the arguments some mod made and this could be the place for that.
All posts should follow this basic structure:
Expect to receive feedback about your posts, they might even be negative.
Make sure you follow this instance's code of conduct. In other words we won't allow bellyaching about being sanctioned for hate speech or bigotry.
YTPB matrix channel: For real-time discussions about bastards or to appeal mod actions in YPTB itself.
Some acronyms you might see.
Relevant comms
lol I was banned today for “failure to grow” because i did not have the proper thinking.
It was on me though. I should not have commented there, knowing what happens regularly.
A.S Has a very itchy ban finger generally and often assumes everyone is as knowledgeable as them so they tend to see behavior like yours as deliberate trolling (or in your case, likely crypto-fascism). It's really the sort of place one needs to "lurk moar" before interacting. I personally don't like how hostile their instance treats people stumbling in, because it often causes drama and false positives like this, but OTOH this allows them to run a tight ship and not have to deal with cryptofash and libertarian shite which can be exhausting.
Ultimately it is what it is and A.S has a tiny impact on the threadiverse relatively. Other than that I agree that it's not cool to label people fascists at the drop of a hat in the modlog but perhaps their admins will pop in and explain if they saw actual fash behaviour.
I can see that, and thanks for the explanation. I clicked around a bit after to double-check rules and see if I got the context wrong. But yeah, seems like it was my inexperience with the community and aggressive modding.
Got a perma ban from there for reporting another user that jumped straight to cussing me out after I gently corrected a typo they made. Ended up with a ban because (shockingly) another user also found that disproportionate and reported as well, and the admin accused us of collaborative "spurious reporting" 🙄 They also hid it from the modlog somehow/for some reason. Found that pretty sketchy.
It's standard lemmy behaviour. If you ban with content removal, the removed content doesn't make a modlog entry
*shrug* All I know is any other ban or comment removal I've seen on my accounts has been accompanied by modlog entries.
it bugs me. language is imprecise and sometimes you get banned and the ban reason doesn't, in your head, map to what you were saying. and then that changes how anyone who looks you up thinks you think. i'd much rather have a system that makes it clear what exactly you said and what the problem was
It might be good to have the option of a right of reply in the modlog for the person being moderated, for each mod action?
Didn't/aren't the devs so anti accountability now that they don't even want mods names connected with actions?
And of course mod names (not even aliases) go on the mod log, which is cool and good. At this point why does it even exist?
They do, it's just lemmy hiding the mod usernames for normal users. Admins can see the moderator names in the mod log.
That's still shitty. More deliberately but less terminally.
Sounds like a pretty
Awful
System of communities
what a dick move to call me a facist in the modlog
Welcome to the club. Mods claiming people are fascists in public places they can't defend themselves seems to be a common occurrence here.
It's fucking weird how that word gets used against everyone and everything on this platform.
I got banned with "fascist" as the only notes because I said tiananmen square happened. That's all. Didn't deny it, or say 100 million were killed in it. Just that the event as described happened.
If you have a single original thought that isn't 99% aligned with the mods on users of that instance, that's what happens, you're fascist /s
I'm in. As long as there's snacks at the meetings.
What you said in the context you gave and the words in your removed comment track, so I'm gonna say PTB.
Thanks, yo.
I even posted my old account info on my profile page when I joined a new instance, for transparency, with a comment history going back more than two years, showing I'm way more of a chronically online queer socialist.
I've never been banned for (supposedly) being a fascist... but I've been banned plenty of times by shitlibs for (supposedly) being a tankie.
Yeah I blocked that instance since time back, their takes (and attitudes) were generally as awful as the systems they complain about
They are just assholes. Its really simple. You don't want to be there.
plenty of Lemmy instances love calling fact checking and sources "Facism"